Home » SEALED Concrete FLOORS vs POLISHED Concrete FLOORS Pros and Cons

SEALED Concrete FLOORS vs POLISHED Concrete FLOORS Pros and Cons

LUXURY CONCRETE FLOORS

Craftsman Concrete

Concrete Floor Finishing Basics

There are a million different styles of concrete floor finishes, and let’s face it, captions under Pinterest pictures do a really bad job of identifying the installation technique you’re admiring. In fact, when having an initial consultation with a new customer, a primary issue we face is that most people have difficulty identifying the finish they desire.

It’s not you’re fault! This is a confusing subject that this page will clear up. These finishes have very different benefits and drawbacks, so it’s really important to have a basic understanding of these finishes before making a decision on a concrete floor install.

This page discusses the differences between polished concrete and sealed concrete. To learn more about sealed concrete, visit our main sealed concrete floors page

The Two Types of Concrete Floor Finishes

It might be hard to believe, but there are really only two different types of concrete floor finish: sealed concrete and polished concrete.

Sealed concrete, however, is a giant category. The most basic sealed concrete floor is simply an acrylic sealer installed over bare concrete. However, sealed concrete also includes all types of stained concrete as well as commercial coatings such as epoxy and polyurethane.

Polished concrete is a very different installation. Polished concrete floors depend on penetrating liquids called silicate densifiers and stain guards to eliminate concrete porosity and prevent staining. Don’t worry if this sounds confusing, we’ll go into more detail on this later. What’s important to keep in mind is that there’s no film covering a polished concrete floor. Polished concrete, as its name suggests, is also mechanically honed to achieve the desired level of reflectivity and consistency.

Goals of Concrete Floor Finishing

Let’s back up a bit and just ask “what are the goals of concrete floor finishing?”

Fundamentally, the goal of all concrete floor finishing is to protect a concrete slab from staining and abrasion.

This is where the major distinction between whether to seal concrete floor or to polish it exists:

SEALED CONCRETE PROTECTS A CONCRETE FLOOR BY ADDING A FILM OVER THE ENTIRE SURFACE, WHILE POLISHED CONCRETE USES PENETRATING LIQUIDS TO PREVENT STAINING.

More About Sealed Concrete

Just from reading the content above, it’s easy to come to the conclusion that sealed concrete probably does a better job of protecting a floor from staining than polished concrete. In most cases that’s correct, however, sealed concrete has some serious drawbacks that must be considered. We’ll discuss these more later, but here’s a very basic overview of the benefits and drawbacks of sealed concrete floors.

BENEFITS OF SEALED CONCRETE

  • High stain and chemical resistance
  • Fast install time
  • High gloss
  • Low cost for basic installations

DRAWBACKS OF SEALED CONCRETE

  • High potential for failure
  • Difficult or impossible to repair
  • Quickly shows scratches and wear patterns
  • Slippery, especially when wet

When to Install Sealed Concrete Floors

STAINED CONCRETE

When most people think of concrete floors, they think of stained concrete. This is primarily due to the fact that this installation has been around for over 100 years. However, it might surprise you to learn that only a small fraction of new residential concrete installations are stained concrete. Stained concrete always requires a concrete floor sealing coat to prevent the color from wearing off, so it should functionally be considered sealed concrete—it has the same set of benefits and drawbacks.

Looking for more Information About Stained Concrete Floors? Visit our main stained concrete floors page

Basement Concrete Floors and Foundation Walls

When sealing basement floor, it’s an absolute necessity to apply a waterproof basement floor sealer. Foundation walls and the concrete basement floor need waterproofing sealers to lock out moisture and protect the foundation of your house. An epoxy coating makes a perfect basement concrete floor sealer to maintain and preserve your space.

How to Seal Concrete Floor in The Basement?

When opting for an epoxy coating for your basement floor, be sure to apply the epoxy to a cool floor, which will help it stick to the surface. Choose a long-handled roller to apply a thin coat of epoxy. If you need a second coat, be sure to allow the first coat to dry for 24 hours before applying the second.

GARAGE FLOORS

At Craftsman Concrete Floors, we regularly install both sealed and polished concrete in residential garages. To settle the debate of concrete polishing vs epoxy coating for your garage floor, it depends on whether your project is new construction and how you’ll be using your garage. If you’re a gearhead, hobbyist mechanic, or have cars that might leak fluids, then epoxy, a high-quality garage floor sealing coat, is absolutely the installation for you.

Polished concrete can only be installed in garages that are new construction. Garages that have already seen significant vehicle traffic are often already too stained or worn to be properly polished.

More About Epoxy Garage Floors

Luxury epoxy garage floors are generally installed as a three-part system: a 100% solids epoxy base coat, a coat of epoxy flakes with 100% coverage, and a polyurethane topcoat. While this can start to get a bit technical, there’s one giant advantage that these floors have that other sealed concrete floors don’t—they’re repairable. Because of the epoxy flake layer, if an epoxy garage floor is scratched to the point of being damaged, new epoxy flakes and polyurethane topcoats can be seamlessly installed. While this type of damage is exceedingly rare, this characteristic makes epoxy flake the most durable installation for garages that will see serious use.

Some seriously cool cars on a luxury epoxy garage floor finish. This Highland Park, Texas installation used exclusively Westcoat products—the industry leader in these systems. This installation will hold up for decades.

Some seriously cool cars on a luxury epoxy garage floor finish. This Highland Park, Texas installation used exclusively Westcoat products—the industry leader in these systems. This installation will hold up for decades.

Drawbacks of Sealed Concrete Floors

SEALED CONCRETE FLOORS CAN FAIL!

The most critical drawback of sealed concrete is its high potential for failure.

You’re probably asking, ‘how does a sealed concrete floor fail?’ In most cases, the sealer simply starts to separate from the concrete it was applied to. To make things worse, in nearly all cases of failure the entire floor must be resurfaced and resealed in order to achieve an aesthetic appearance. Sealed concrete is simply not a repairable concrete floor installation.

Of the various reasons concrete sealers fail, the most common is poor surface preparation.

Concrete preparation requires specialized equipment, so it’s generally not possible for anyone other than a concrete floor installer to properly install a sealed concrete floor. In fact, even with proper preparation sealed concrete floors generally have much shorter lifespans than polished concrete floors.

Notice the tiger-striped areas on this luxury residential floor. This sealer has catastrophically failed!  It was installed by a painting company without proper preparation of the slab. Repairing this floor cost about four times what a proper install would have cost, leaving this home owner with a considerable repair bill.
Notice the tiger-striped areas on this luxury residential floor. This sealer has catastrophically failed!
It was installed by a painting company without proper preparation of the slab. Repairing this floor cost about four times what a proper install would have cost, leaving this home owner with a considerable repair bill.

The other primary reason sealed concrete floors fail is due to excessive vapor pressure in the concrete slab. While this is a very technical subject that’s outside the purview of this article, this failure is the result of moisture in the slab becoming trapped under the sealer. Here in Texas, where it’s extremely humid, these types of failures are extremely common.

Only sealed concrete floors can fail due to excessive moisture. Because polished concrete floors do not have a film on their surface, they release moisture naturally without any impact on their finish.

A heavily scratched ‘stained and sealed’ concrete floor. These scratches required repairs to the entire home to resolve.
A heavily scratched ‘stained and sealed’ concrete floor. These scratches required repairs to the entire home to resolve.

SCRATCHING AND OTHER WEAR

Another major drawback of sealed concrete floors is their propensity for showing scratches and wear in high traffic areas. This is due to the fact that the coating on top of the concrete simply isn’t as durable as the concrete it’s bonded to. Over time, this coating is slowly worn down to the underlying concrete slab, leaving unsightly wear patterns in high traffic areas. No matter the type of floor or variety of concrete sealer, some scratching and wear should be expected on a sealed concrete floor.

SEALED CONCRETE FLOORS ARE EXPENSIVE TO REPAIR

We frequently get phone calls from residential customers who tried to save money by having sealed concrete installed by an unqualified contractor, only to have the sealer start to fail shortly after installation.

Unfortunately for these homeowners, they often find that repairing their floors costs many times what the initial installation did. For most sealed concrete failures, the entire floor must be stripped or ground and a new coat of sealer applied. This is much more labor-intensive than the initial installation!

In most cases, after the failure of a sealed concrete floor, our customers decide to switch to a polished concrete installation. While the upfront cost is higher, properly installed polished concrete floors cannot fail and require little to no maintenance.

Failed! — Stained Concrete Gallery

While we did not install any of these floors, we regularly get maintenance and repair requests for damaged floors. Below are some common examples of issues seen on poorly installed floors.

More About Polished Concrete

If you’re a residential builder or homeowner considering concrete floors, pay attention to this statistic—over 95% of our residential customers choose polished concrete for their interior floors. Polished concrete floors simply look better and last longer than sealed concrete floors. Below is a very basic overview of the benefits and drawbacks of polished concrete floors.

BENEFITS OF POLISHED CONCRETE

  • Extremely high durability and low maintenance
  • Natural, beautiful appearance
  • Extremely high slip resistance
  • Gloss levels from matte to mirror
  • No volatile chemicals used during installation

DRAWBACKS OF POLISHED CONCRETE

  • Lower stain resistance
  • Slower installation time
  • Higher installation cost
  • Less well suited for certain industrial and exterior installations

Residential Polished Concrete Gallery